|
According to Jerome Bruner's 1994
article, "the 'remembered' self," we constantly recreate our our
understanding of "self" (53).
In this process of re-creation we often use autobiography to explain away
the differences, discrepancies, and anomalies that inevitably occur as we
move through time. How we change and grow, how we alter our understanding
of who we are -- these are activities for which personal narratives (whether
internal or shared with others) are vitally necessary.
In Bruner's research, the subjects
were found to have, on the whole, a fluent ability to reconcile events in
their lives which might be identified as "out of character" or "dissonant"
with their sense of self. He notes that the reconciliation of these accounts
seems to require the use of an autobiographical style which sees the author
as agent, and in fact, "the 'feel' of agency in our lives is ... what
is most likely to undergo exaggeration in the remembering" (48). This
sense of agency allows narrators to reduce the cognitive dissonance which
occurs when anomalous events are recounted (47).
The introduction to Patricia
Hill Collins' Fighting Words: Black Women and the Search for Justice,
can serve as an example of the strength of agency in autobiographical narratives.
Collins shares a story of the discrepancies she saw as a second-grade teacher
between the sense of "community" promoted by the curriculum of her
school and the radically different sense of community experienced by her students,
who mostly "resided in a nearby racially segregated public housing project"
(ix).
At that moment,
I faced an important choice. I could teach the status quo or I could
teach for a change. I did not see how I could lie to my students, no
matter how pure my intentions to prepare them for an imagined third-grade
entrance test on community vocabulary. So we closed those texts full
of smiling, affluent White people and began to talk. (x).
|
Collins' narration
of this moment positions herself, and to some extent the students, as agents
of change. However, in describing his research Bruner also mentions Patricia
Williams' text The Alchemy of Race and Rights" as an example of
autobiographical writing in which the sense of agency is complicated and transformed
by social and cultural pressures.
Some of the stories in this text
(told by me or contributed by others)
are akin to those of Williams, and could be considered remarkable for the
absence or complications of agency they present. These stories, although autobiographical,
are closer to what Bruner (in reference to Charles Taylor) calls "radical
reflection" (49). They do the work of disruption rather than the work
of unification. The memories and experiences remain complex and poorly fitted
to the work of creating a unified self; nevertheless, they may help me to
create a more malleable sense of self, better suited to the work of examining
race in my life and relationships.
The ability to utilize (or disrupt)
a sense of personal agency through narrative is further developed by scholars
such as Nedra Reynolds. Reynolds asserts that "agency is not simply about
finding one's own voice but also about intervening in discourses of the everyday
and cultivating rhetorical tactics that make interruptions and resistance
an important part of any conversation" (59).
However, Reynolds' stance regarding the status of "agency" as "more
than personal" may in some ways illustrate the tendency that Min Zhan
Lu describes, where "experiences which do not fit directly and neatly
within simplistic notions of race, sex, class, and gender identity are then
dismissed as private, non-political, and therefore irrelevant" (175).
Additionally, Reynolds notes that
the importance and potential for interruption and resistance as rhetorical
strategies are "most effective in the spaces where physical presence
heightens the effect -- at conferences, in classrooms, around tables"
(71). I'm not sure how the spaces of an electronic text such as this might
be adapted to the goals of interruption and resistance.
My vision for these texts is
that they might touch all of these boundaries.
To be both personal and social
Public and private
Acts of agency and acts of reflection.
To interrupt and connect.
To testify, witness, and critique.
|
In other words (and in a collage
of others' words) I am trying to interrupt myself. To create spaces for personal
reflection that are open for public examination, and to connect through these
texts to others (known and unknown) in interactions that encourage both movement
and reflection.
|