Essay 3 Peer Response Assignment: Writing a
A Collaborative Project for Internet Publication
PEER RESPONSE GROUP: For this assignment you will work with an assigned group of students from our three colleges. This group of students will serve as your critical readers in the same way that your in-class peer group has done for the first two essays. You will share draft 2 with them via e-mail and in return they will ask you to read and respond to their essays. Follow the instructions for peer response work given on the next page and be sure to meet all deadlines set on your class schedule;
STEPS FOR PEER GROUP RESPONSE:
Make initial e-mail contact once you have been assigned your peer group and given e-mail addresses:
|
|
Share coversheet and draft 2 of Essay 3 with your peer group via e-mail.
|
|
Respond to your peers’ coversheets and essays, answering the questions on page 4 of this handout. |
|
Get suggestions from your peer group for names for the website and nominate one name for your group. Then, students from all three colleges will select the name from peer group nominations |
ESSAY 3 PEER RESPONSE QUESTIONS FOR E-MAIL REPLY
Instructions: (1) Read all your peer group members’ coversheets and drafts at least twice, and (2) e-mail each writer your responses to all the questions below. You do not have to rewrite questions. Just number and write a response with a topic sentence that indicates your subject (e.g., My first reactions in reading this draft were. . . ).
Give the essay’s title. |
|
What were your reactions when first reading this draft? |
|
What is the writer’s purpose? How well does that purpose address the writing assignment? |
|
What is the writer’s role? Is that role appropriate for the purpose of the essay? |
|
To what audience is the essay directed? |
|
Does the targeted audience address the assignment requirements? |
|
Does the writer describe the audience sufficiently on the coversheet? If not, what else is needed? |
|
List at least two examples that show how this essay appeals to the needs of this audience. Refer to specific tone, word choice, details included, format, and so forth. |
|
What dominant impression of the profile subject does the essay make? |
|
Is the dominant impression expressed or implied by a thesis? Is the thesis specific enough? If not, make suggestions for narrowing the focus. |
|
Reread each paragraph, noting whether it is related to the thesis of the essay. Identify any paragraphs that do not seem to relate to the essay’s thesis. |
|
Comment on how well the writer has covered of the topic, discussing the who, what, where, when, how, and why of the profile? |
|
List some of the most interesting information you learned about the subject. |
|
List some of the information you found least interesting or off the subject of the profile. |
|
Identify any information that confused you. |
|
Identify points that needed more development. |
|
Comment on the clarity and correctness of the writer’s language and identify any technical terms that need defined. |
|
Comment on the writer’s use of sources (interview and publications): sufficient? clear? correctly documented? |
|
Comment on the effectiveness of the opening paragraph to get the readers’ attention, establish a dominant impression, and introduce the readers to the essay’s perspective. |
|
Comment on the effectiveness the closing paragraph to conclude the profile well, reinforcing the dominant impression of the profile subject and ending the essay smoothly. |
|
Conclude your response with any other observations about the coversheet and draft not covered above. |
TASKS AND DUE DATES: Because this assignment requires you to schedule and conduct an interview and work with an off-campus peer group via e-mail, you should start working on the assignment immediately. Your teacher will set specific dates (consult your class schedule) following these time lines:
October 09-13
The writing assignment is distributed and discussed.
Peer groups are assigned.
Peer groups establish contact.
Students submit topic choice, name/qualifications of person to be interviewed, and at least five interview questions.
October 23-27
Interview must be completed.
Students submit invention writing and draft 1.
Students submit coversheet and draft 2 for peer group via e-mail.
Peer groups respond to essays via e-mail.
October 30-November 03
Students submit coversheet and draft 3 to teacher.
Students complete questionnaire and reflective writing on collaborative project in class.
Peer groups nominate names for website and all students vote to select winning name.
November 06-10
Teachers return draft 3 with comments for revision.
November 27-December 01
Students submit draft 4, the final revised essay (hard and disk copies) for publication. Please follow these submission requirements:
1.Three hard copies of the essay with coversheet
2.One copy of essay only (no coversheet) in Word format on 3.5” floppy
disk with the file name: Last name,
initials, college name (i.e.:doejrmtsu)